How Juventus lost 15 points at the secretariat (and how it could have been worse)

On Sunday night time, a banner outdoors the stadium welcomed anybody who got here to observe the Juventus-Atalanta match. “Serie A or Serie B, we’re at all times right here only for Juventus FC.” It was considered one of many expressions of discontent from supporters in the face of a brand new scandal that’s removed from over. Juventus was condemned to drop 15 points in the league, falling to ninth place. The draw with Atalanta (3-3) means they now have 23 points and, though coach Massimiliano Allegri tries to look forward, altering the math, the state of affairs is bleak. And it could be worse.

While the membership is getting ready to enchantment this primary sentence, there are a number of processes initiated in the sports activities court docket, along with the judicial investigation that results in the course of and there shall be a preliminary determination at the finish of March. And there’s nonetheless a UEFA investigation into attainable non-compliance with monetary truthful play. 17 years after «Calciopoli», which resulted in the administrative descent of the division, the Turin big finds himself concerned in a course of with very totally different contours, however which has shaken the complete construction of membership and threatened with additional penalties. In the coming months, it shall be clear what they’re and if there shall be results on different golf equipment as properly.

Investigations centered on suspicions of manipulation of accounts to cowl up losses. The case got here to gentle in November 2021, when Italian justice searched the Juventus services. The investigation by “Prisma”, managed by the prosecutor’s workplace in Turin, was launched in May and goals to research, in line with the authorities, “attainable crimes of false reporting by listed firms and issuing the invoices, for non-transactions” between 2019 and 2021, checking for these “numerous operations of the switch {of professional} gamers and the companies supplied by a few of the brokers concerned”.

A course of with 14 thousand pages

The investigation of the Turin prosecutor’s workplace is linked to a different, performed by Consob, the Italian authority for regulating the capital market, which can also be centered on suspected fictitious capital positive factors and which questions many transfers, most of which involving Juventus and its managers, but in addition different golf equipment, resembling Napoli. From there the sports activities justice opened a primary course of, which in April 2022 resulted in the acquittal of these concerned. That determination was confirmed in May by the highest disciplinary physique of the Italian Federation, which thought-about, amongst different elements, that there is no such thing as a goal technique to judge the worth of gamers and transfers, so it just isn’t attainable to -ot the conclusions about attainable fraud.

But the judicial investigation by the prosecutor’s workplace in Turin continues, focusing solely on Juventus. The investigation resulted in a 14,000-page course of, which included the assortment of documentation but in addition the listening and interception of messages between a number of Juventus leaders at the time. It has a number of facets, all associated to attainable monetary irregularities. On the one hand, there are suspicions of capital positive factors via inflated transfers of gamers, the so-called capital positive factors. On the different hand, the case is about the discount in the wage of the gamers introduced by Juventus in 2020, in the midst of the covid pandemic, with suspicions that there’s additionally a maneuver with the goal of artificially bettering the membership’s accounts.

The wage of the gamers and the “Carta Ronaldo”

Many particulars of the investigation had been printed in the Italian press, with an estimated 155 million fictitious capital obtained at stake and with the counting of suspicious companies, resembling the switch of the Portuguese João Cancelo to Manchester City or the alternate of Arthur Pjanic with Barcelona. Last yr, a number of hearings performed as a part of the investigation had been additionally printed.

Justice additionally heard many gamers, in the context of the case of wage discount. In the press, Chiellini’s alleged testimony was printed, during which the former captain of Juventus admitted that, though it was reported that the gamers accepted a four-month wage discount resulting from the pandemic, it was agreed that the gamers would give. in only one month, obtain the remaining quantity later. A doc thought-about vital for this investigation is the «Carta Ronaldo», a «secret» doc during which Juve dedicated to pay nearly 20 million to the Portuguese participant and which is able to show the thesis of the deferred cost. Last week, «Corriere della Sera» printed what it claimed to be that letter, and which was signed by the director Fabio Paratici, however not by Cristiano Ronaldo.

The finish of the Andrea Agnelli period and monetary collapse

The siege tightened round Juventus and at the finish of November 2022 the board led by Andrea Agnelli resigned en bloc. It was the finish of an period. Agnelli led the membership since 2010 and through that point Juventus invested rather a lot and was capable of lead sportingly internally, however by no means achieved what was the principal objective, profitable the (*15*) League. The membership’s funds had been in tatters, regardless of a sequence of capital will increase by the mum or dad firm, Exor, managed by the Agnelli household. Last yr, Juventus introduced report losses of 254 million euros.

The departure of the director didn’t ease the examine of the authorized points surrounding Juventus. In December 2022, the sports activities justice determined to request the reopening of the case in opposition to the membership, claiming new information ensuing from the judicial investigation. It was the reopening of that case that led to the convictions introduced Friday night time.

After the federal prosecutor’s workplace requested for a penalty of the lack of 9 points for Juventus, the Court of Appeal determined to extend the sentence, eradicating 15 points, with impact this season. In addition, he utilized a number of suspensions, involving Andrea Agnelli or Pavel Nedved, vp of the membership, but in addition two lively administrators: Fabio Paratici, who’s now director of Tottenham, and Federico Cherubini, director of sport of Juventus. On the different hand, the different golf equipment concerned and their administrators – Sampdoria, Pro Vercelli, Genoa, Parma, Pisa, Empoli, Novara and Pescara – had been acquitted. Napoli is not concerned on this course of, however solely the golf equipment related to the suspected offers with Juventus.

The processes that observe

This determination solely pertains to considered one of the ongoing sports activities justice proceedings. There are two extra, with selections anticipated quickly. One of them has to do with the participant’s wage case. Others have many suspicions of fictitious capital positive factors, which in flip contain different golf equipment in the enterprise of Juventus.

As for the judicial investigation, it shall be selected March 27 whether or not felony fees shall be introduced in opposition to the membership and its former leaders.

Finally, after the entire scandal, UEFA reopened an investigation with Juventus in December, to research “potential violations of the rules” of economic truthful play. Last August, the membership reached an settlement with the European physique, which now admits to canceling it and making use of further disciplinary sanctions if it concludes that the assumptions of that settlement have modified.

The causes for the sentence that condemned Juventus to the lack of 15 points and, on the different hand, acquitted the different golf equipment concerned aren’t but identified. The membership’s attorneys spoke of “unfair remedy” and there have been many voices questioning the incontrovertible fact that solely Juventus was blamed for a apply utilized by many different golf equipment. “We should perceive that this technique is utilized by many golf equipment, this downside should be solved as soon as and for all and for all», former participant Claudio Marchisio informed RAI, for instance, emphasizing that « these accountable should work on this downside, which we see not solely in Italy but in addition in Europe.»

The course of relies on a whole lot of information that points to a scientific apply of manipulating Juventus’ accounts and the revelations made by the press level to the concept that those that handle the membership “self-condemned” the illegalities. Reinforcing this concept, a phrase from the former monetary supervisor of Juve, Stefano Bertola, emerged from the listening to and revealed: “In the final 15 years, solely Calciopoli has been as dangerous as this. At that point we had been attacked from all sides. But this time we created it.”

After studying the causes for the sentence, Juventus has a month to enchantment to the Sports Guarantee College of the Italian Olympic Committee. This physique doesn’t consider the course of itself, however solely attainable defects in type, and will verify or annul the sentence.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *